My Attempt at One of Cinema’s Greatest Monlogues

Despite it's age, It's A Wonderful Life remains one of the most watched holiday films of all time (and for good reason).
Directed by Frank Capra and released in 1946, the film was not considered a success during its initial release. But thanks to the dawn of television, it experienced a surge in popularity and has enjoyed a longevity that very few films from that era have been able to maintain.
What some deem the film's greatest weakness, many of us deem its greatest strength: sentiment.
"...the weakness of this picture, from this reviewer's point of view, is the sentimentality of it—its illusory concept of life." (Bosley Crowther, New York Times)
Sentimentality can be an effective and powerfully motivating tool, and It's A Wonderful Life wielded it with rare precision.
I, for one, would much rather aspire to ideals than settle for dim, hopeless depictions of "reality."
I've greatly enjoyed the film since I was a kid (especially the scene where everyone falls in the pool under the dance floor, for obvious reasons), but the older I get, the more it resonates with me on a deeper, difficult-to-explain level. Jimmy Stewart and George Bailey (where one ends and the other begins is difficult to tell) tapped into something special. A rare piece of art that accurately depitcts the struggle of "the common man." The tension of aspirations vs. the responsibility to family, friends, and community. The feelings of inadequacy, the stresses of providing for a family, the failures as a husband and father - I've experienced them all. Many of us have.
But in the end (and arguably, most importantly), the film lands us exactly where we need it (and want it) to land: Home. Our lives, no matter how messy they are, are indeed wonderful when we count our blessings (starting with the ones that live within the walls of our home).
On a more personal note, Jimmy Stewart was one of the main inspirations behind my decision to pursue a career in film. Specifically, his roles in It's A Wonderful Life and Mr. Smith Goes to Washington. I wanted to tell stories like that. Stories of underdogs overcoming adversity, of light triumphing over darkness, of small town heroes with big dreams.
So as a tribute to the legacy of Mr. Stewart and Capra's classic film, I did something last week I've been meaning to do for a long time, but have been hesitant to do so: I took an entire morning to memorize the famous monologue from It's A Wonderful Life, study Jimmy Stewart's delivery of it, rehearse it, film it in an empty Sunday school classroom, and edit it.
It's definitely not an exact impersonation, but I did my best to evoke the spirit of the scene and include touches of Jimmy's performance throughout, both with body language and vocal intonation.
After sharing it on social media, I was so encouraged by all of the incredibly encouraging comments from so many long-time fans of the film and Jimmy Stewart, a few of which I'll highlight below:
"Impressive." - Daniel Harmon | Co-Founder of Angel Studios and Creator/Showrunner of Tuttle Twins
"Well done!!!" - Jarod O'Flaherty | Director of Vindication
"Hey, Burns and Co.! With just a liiiiiittle bit of polish, here’s your Jimmy Stewart for your biopic! 👏🏻👏🏻" -
Ashley Cicotte
And speaking of biopic - yes, there is one in the works!
Burns & Co. is currently developing
A Truly Wonderful Life, produced by Aaron Burns, Angela Galgani Sullivan, Justin Strawhand, and executive produced by Sam Juergens and Kelly Stewart (Jimmy Stewart's daughter).
The logline on IMDb simply reads,
"America's most iconic actor and the role that saved him."
Here's the Deadline article that broke the exclusive story if you'd like to learn a bit more about it.
Although the film is already in development, I've decided to dream big and pray that I'm somehow able to play a part in bringing Stewart's story to the silver screen, whether it be as an actor, a composer, or a PA. Feel free to dream big and pray with me if you're so inclined!
To everyone who read this far and took the time to check out my work, THANK YOU! It means a lot.
And remember...
"No man is a failure who has friends."



